Identities Journal Blog
  • Home
  • About
    • About Identities
    • Identities Collection
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Issues
    • Open Access Articles
    • Most Read Articles
    • Most Cited Articles
  • Identities Blog
    • Blog Collection
    • About Our Blog
    • Blog Categories >
      • Anti-racism
      • Culture
      • Decoloniality
      • Ethnicity
      • Migration
      • Race
      • Commentaries
      • COVID-19 Blog Series
      • COVID-19 Symposium
      • More Blogs
    • Blog Series >
      • COVID-19 Blog Collection
      • Call for COVID-19 Commentaries
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events >
      • Fireside Chat with Prof Nicola Rollock
    • Past Events >
      • Race and Class
      • W. E. B. Du Bois and his Strange Synthesis of Spirituality and Sociology
      • Decolonizing Politics Symposium
      • The Subject of Decolonization: Literary Critical Insights
  • Contact
    • Subscribe for Updates
  • Home
  • About
    • About Identities
    • Identities Collection
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Issues
    • Open Access Articles
    • Most Read Articles
    • Most Cited Articles
  • Identities Blog
    • Blog Collection
    • About Our Blog
    • Blog Categories >
      • Anti-racism
      • Culture
      • Decoloniality
      • Ethnicity
      • Migration
      • Race
      • Commentaries
      • COVID-19 Blog Series
      • COVID-19 Symposium
      • More Blogs
    • Blog Series >
      • COVID-19 Blog Collection
      • Call for COVID-19 Commentaries
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events >
      • Fireside Chat with Prof Nicola Rollock
    • Past Events >
      • Race and Class
      • W. E. B. Du Bois and his Strange Synthesis of Spirituality and Sociology
      • Decolonizing Politics Symposium
      • The Subject of Decolonization: Literary Critical Insights
  • Contact
    • Subscribe for Updates

The role of nativist discourse in racist ideology

10/11/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
'Refugees must be taught how to best fit in': so reads the title of Times columnist Clare Foges following the fall of Afghanistan in August 2021 to the Taliban and the subsequent mass exodus of Afghan men, women and children towards Britain. This wilfully juxtaposes a ‘non-native’ other with the presumed ‘natives’ of the UK and places expectations on the new arrivals to adapt to ‘our way of life’. This emphasis on assimilation and the eradication of difference and is one of the core demands often placed on the racialised ‘non-native’, ‘foreigner’ or ‘non-integrated’ co-citizen on their arrival to the West. It is but one of many recent examples of a far right discourse of ‘nativism’ being published in a mainstream broadsheet, and passed off as ‘sensible politics’.
             
Much of the scholarship on the far right has taken an ‘ideational approach’ to nativism which entails the following three assumptions:

  1. Nativism is an ideology, and thus as a belief system, which gives preference to ‘natives’ and considers ‘non-natives’ as a threat to the homogenous nation-state
  2. What defines this ideology is a combination (to varying degrees and extents) of xenophobia, nationalism, populism and racism
  3. Nativism is predominantly a far right (or radical right) phenomenon.
The ideational approach has spawned a wide range of paradigms which define nativism as a ‘combination of nationalism and xenophobia’, a ‘subset of American racism and nationalism’, as ‘non-racist’, ‘race neutral’, or a blend of ‘nationalism and populism’. Such an approach tends to neglect the fuzzy borders between these concepts, underestimate of the process of racialisation in the juxtaposition of the native against the non-native, conflate nativism with populism, and ignore the presence of nativism in the mainstream. This euphemises and conceals the racist ideology behind anti-migrant and anti-refugee messages.
 
My Identities article, ‘Rethinking ‘Nativism’: beyond the ideational approach’, while not negating the importance of ideology, shifts the focus from what is the assumed ‘ideational content’ of political phenomena to how political actors formulate this supposed content. Rather than representing a form of nationalism, nativism is interpreted as:
 
a racist and xenophobic discourse structured around an exclusionary vision of ‘the nation’ in which the ‘native’ is discursively constructed as a disadvantaged and threatened ‘in-group’ through its juxtaposition along antagonistic and horizontal lines to a racialised ‘non-native’, ‘foreigner’, or ‘non-integrated co-citizen’.
 
My definition helps identify how nativism operates in the blurred lines between exclusionary nationalism, xenophobia, racism and racialisation. By presenting nativism as a political logic and discourse the article represents a departure from the aforementioned ideational approaches which have tended to conflate the term not only with racism, but also populism, thus equipping such ideas with a veneer of ‘popular will’.
 
It is my hope that my new definition of nativism may help scholars identify such discourse for what it is: a discursive feature of racist ideology.I advocate for a more critical engagement with the term nativism, avoiding its use as a proxy for racism. This can be done by bearing in mind the following three rules of engagement:

1.  Nativism’s logic is racist not populist  

The logic of nativism relies on the three following elements:
The presentation of immigration as a threat to the nation (or region)
A racist and racialised process of othering

An emphasis on ‘assimilation’, ‘acceptable transformation of the problem of difference’, or ‘stopping the invasion’.Identifying this logic allows us to draw a clearer distinction from that of populism which in its juxtaposition of ‘the people’ versus ‘the elites’ does not have to eradicate the differences between the different groups and demands that are grouped under ‘the people’.

2.  Nativism is a racist and xenophobic discourse  

Viewing nativism as ‘non-racist’ or ‘race-neutral’ contributes to the euphemising of racist ideology. Instead, by viewing nativism as a key discursive feature of racist ideology it is possible to see it as operating very much within the same logic of exclusionary practices which cause so much harm to marginalised and racialised groups. It ties race and nationality together to portray the ‘native’ as a disadvantaged group being exploited by ‘non-natives’

3. Nativism forms part of the ‘extreme’ and the ‘mainstream’  

​From Nigel Farage’s ‘Breaking Point’ posters in the Brexit campaign and Theresa May’s ‘Go Home Vans’ to Gordon Brown’s pledge of ‘British jobs for British workers’, nativist discourse operates from the right to the left and both within the extreme and the mainstream. The Times’ proselytizing tone of ‘teaching refugees how best to fit in’, therefore, provides but the most recent example of nativist discourse, which is far from new to mainstream media or politics. Understanding the fuzzy borders between the far right and the mainstream, and that the mainstream is not inherently progressive or good, is therefore essential in identifying nativist discourse. 

​While a discourse of ‘strong national borders’ that accompanied the so-called ‘migrant crisis’ has accelerated in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the previous decade has also witnessed a rise of Islamophobia in Europe and the US, the Windrush scandal in the UK and the mobilisation of the Black Lives Matter movement. All of these events have raised questions about ‘in-groups’ and ‘out-groups’ with perceived ‘non-native’ and racialised groups being excluded from national belonging.
 
One of the most pressing issues for ‘far right studies’ is a continuous and robust engagement with how racism operates as a key part of far right ideology and how this relates to the mainstream. This entails a move away from paradigms and approaches which (consciously or unconsciously) act to euphemise racist ideas and policies. I maintain that ‘nativism’, as a concept, only has any purpose if it is recognised as a discursive element of racist ideology.
Concepts require constant interrogation and evolution; I, therefore, encourage critical engagement with my definition to further examine the way in which ‘natives’ and ‘non-natives’ are discursively constructed by both extreme and mainstream political actors. 

Image credit: Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash

Blog post by George Newth, University of Bath, UK

Read the Identities article:
Newth, George. Rethinking ‘Nativism’: beyond the ideational approach. Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power. DOI: 10.1080/1070289X.2021.1969161 [OPEN ACCESS]
Picture
Explore other relevant Identities articles:

Claiming the right to belong: de-stigmatisation strategies among Turkish-Dutch Muslims

In pursuit of purity: populist nationalism and the racialization of difference​

Whiteness, populism and the racialisation of the working class in the United Kingdom and the United States
​
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Blog Categories

    All
    Activism
    Anti-racism
    Asylum Seekers
    Belonging
    Black Lives Matter
    Blackness
    Borders
    Boundary Work
    Cities
    Citizenship
    Colonialism
    Commentaries
    Conflict
    Cosmopolitanism
    Covid-19
    Cultural Memory
    Culture
    Decoloniality
    Diaspora
    Discrimination
    Displacement
    Diversity
    Ethnic Boundaries
    Ethnic Identity
    Ethnicity
    Exile
    Far Right
    Gender
    Global South
    Identity
    Immigration
    Indigenous
    Integration
    Intersectionality
    Islamophobia
    Justice
    Kinship
    Marginalisation
    Migration
    Multiculturalism
    National Identity
    Nationalism
    Nationhood
    Nativism
    Othering
    Policing
    Populism
    Postcolonial
    Race
    Racial Identity
    Racialisation
    Racism
    Radicalism
    Refugees
    Religion
    Resistance
    State Racism
    Stereotyping
    Stigmatisation
    Subjectivity
    Transnationalism
    Victimhood
    Whiteness


    Blog Collection

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019

Explore Identities at tandfonline.com/GIDE