Identities Journal Blog
  • Home
  • About
    • About Identities
    • Identities Collection
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Issues
    • Open Access Articles
    • Most Read Articles
    • Most Cited Articles
  • Identities Blog
    • Blog Collection
    • About Our Blog
    • Blog Categories >
      • Anti-racism
      • Culture
      • Decoloniality
      • Ethnicity
      • Migration
      • Race
      • Commentaries
      • COVID-19 Blog Series
      • COVID-19 Symposium
      • More Blogs
    • Blog Series >
      • COVID-19 Blog Collection
      • Call for COVID-19 Commentaries
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events >
      • Fireside Chat with Prof Nicola Rollock
    • Past Events >
      • Race and Class
      • W. E. B. Du Bois and his Strange Synthesis of Spirituality and Sociology
      • Decolonizing Politics Symposium
      • The Subject of Decolonization: Literary Critical Insights
  • Contact
    • Subscribe for Updates
  • Home
  • About
    • About Identities
    • Identities Collection
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Issues
    • Open Access Articles
    • Most Read Articles
    • Most Cited Articles
  • Identities Blog
    • Blog Collection
    • About Our Blog
    • Blog Categories >
      • Anti-racism
      • Culture
      • Decoloniality
      • Ethnicity
      • Migration
      • Race
      • Commentaries
      • COVID-19 Blog Series
      • COVID-19 Symposium
      • More Blogs
    • Blog Series >
      • COVID-19 Blog Collection
      • Call for COVID-19 Commentaries
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events >
      • Fireside Chat with Prof Nicola Rollock
    • Past Events >
      • Race and Class
      • W. E. B. Du Bois and his Strange Synthesis of Spirituality and Sociology
      • Decolonizing Politics Symposium
      • The Subject of Decolonization: Literary Critical Insights
  • Contact
    • Subscribe for Updates

Fixing the underrepresentation of BAME participants in medical research

5/1/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Cross-posted from RACE.ED

​It has been widely reported that the COVID-19 pandemic has disproportionately impacted Black and Ethnic Minority (BAME) communities across the UK, which have suffered higher rates of hospitalisation and mortality. While the causes of this outsized impact are yet to be fully untangled, it is consistent with longstanding disparities in health outcomes and access to medical treatment between BAME communities and the white majority. The pandemic has, in effect, brought pre-existing health inequities to the fore.

With all our hopes for overcoming the pandemic resting on the success of our vaccination programme, it is essential that the jabs being put into arms have been shown to be safe and effective for people across the entire spectrum of our ethnically diverse population.
​
This is important for two reasons. First, medical treatments can have varying effects for people of different ethnic backgrounds, and hence it is essential that clinical trials include volunteers that are representative of the different groups that make up our population. Second, people from BAME backgrounds deserve the same opportunity to build trust in vaccines. This means knowing that vaccines have been rigorously tested on volunteers from their own communities, as well as other groups.
Regrettably, the underrepresentation of BAME volunteers in UK clinical trials and other forms of medical research is pervasive. Such underrepresentation has been identified with respect to treatment development for cardiovascular disease, cancer and dementia. This is despite the fact that these and many other diseases disproportionately affect BAME groups in the UK.
​
This same depressing story seems to be repeating itself in the current pandemic. BAME groups have not only suffered disproportionately from COVID-19, but they have also been underrepresented in clinical trials for vaccine development. Indeed, though people with BAME backgrounds make up 13.8% of the UK population, only 5.7% of those participating in COVID-19 vaccination trials have been from ethnic minorities.

Concern over this underrepresentation is well-founded. One study conducted in the US, for example, found that COVID-19 vaccines trigger a less robust immune response in Asian-Americans than in whites, suggesting that they offer less protection against the disease to this minority group. Considering that COVID-19 vaccines, like the flu jab, will need to be updated each year to tackle new virus strains, it is crucial that people from BAME groups are properly represented in future clinical trials. Otherwise, we risk rolling out yearly vaccines that provide less protection to the highest risk groups, compounding existing health inequities.

Research into the causes of BAME underrepresentation in medical research suggests that rectifying the problem will require a many-pronged approach. The good news is that numerous recommendations for increasing inclusivity have already been proposed by researchers investigating this problem.

One barrier to overcome is a lower level of trust among some BAME groups towards the medical profession. Such mistrust is hardly unwarranted given the experiences of discrimination in healthcare that many BAME individuals report, as well as historical examples of unethical and exploitative clinical trials being performed on ethnic minority groups.

One way that the medical profession could start to rebuild this trust is through better community engagement. By liaising with respected figures from BAME communities – and by giving presentations, answering questions and disseminating informational materials in community settings – medical researchers could raise awareness of the benefits of clinical research while addressing some of the understandable concerns that many in these communities have around such research.

A more practical hurdle to surmount concerns language disparities between those conducting research and potential volunteers from minority ethnic communities. While this problem can be easily solved with the use of interpreters, doing so can incur a high financial cost which funders are often reluctant to cover. Since legislation was introduced in the US to mandate proportional representation of ethnic minority participants in clinical trials run by national institutes, these costs are now routinely factored into research budgets. A similar move in the UK would help to make medical research here more inclusive.

Another barrier to participation is the negative stereotypes that researchers sometimes hold towards BAME individuals. These include beliefs that people from BAME backgrounds are less interested in research and are less likely to stick to research protocols, making researchers holding these stereotypes reluctant to actively recruit from ethnic minority groups in the first place.

One way to address this problem is to provide cultural awareness training to researchers and support staff involved in recruiting and engaging with research participants. This would help to challenge any negative stereotypes currently impeding the recruitment of BAME participants, as well as increasing researchers’ understanding of the concerns that people from different minority ethnic backgrounds can have around medical research.

However, though this would help medical researchers better navigate some of the cultural barriers to recruiting BAME research participants, it represents only a partial solution to a much deeper issue.

Statistics show that people from BAME backgrounds are woefully underrepresented in higher grade positions among university research faculty, yet overrepresented in the lowest grade positions. This means that researchers with the most say over study designs and recruitment procedures are precisely those least likely to come from BAME backgrounds. Increasing the ethnic diversity of more senior research staff should help to address all of the issues discussed here by conferring greater cultural awareness, sensitivity and credibility at the highest levels of research teams.

Increasing the ethnic diversity of research staff is itself a considerable project that would require universities and other centres of medical research to overhaul their recruitment procedures. It is nevertheless essential if progress is to be made and maintained in the long-term. Concrete recommendations include introducing quotas for the number of qualified BAME candidates shortlisted for interview, anonymising applications and offering more flexible working hours.

Achieving proportional BAME representation in medical research will not be achieved overnight. Nevertheless, with a coordinated and concerted effort by government, funders and research institutions, we could start making progress on the necessary changes today.
​
Given the growing health inequalities exacerbated by the current pandemic, the urgency for making these changes has arguably never been greater.

Image credit: Photo by National Cancer Institute on Unsplash

This post was originally published by RACE.ED

​Blog post by Timothy Ijoyemi, Durham University, UK
Picture
Explore other relevant Identities articles:

Race, blood, disease and citizenship: the making of the Haitian-Americans and the Haitian immigrants into ‘the others’ during the 1980s–1990s AIDS crisis

Diversity as discourse and diversity as practice: critical reflections on migrant women’s experiences of accessing mental health support in London

The stigma of being Black in Britain

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Blog Categories

    All
    Activism
    Anti-racism
    Asylum Seekers
    Belonging
    Black Lives Matter
    Blackness
    Borders
    Boundary Work
    Cities
    Citizenship
    Colonialism
    Commentaries
    Conflict
    Cosmopolitanism
    Covid-19
    Cultural Memory
    Culture
    Decoloniality
    Diaspora
    Discrimination
    Displacement
    Diversity
    Ethnic Boundaries
    Ethnic Identity
    Ethnicity
    Exile
    Far Right
    Gender
    Global South
    Identity
    Immigration
    Indigenous
    Integration
    Intersectionality
    Islamophobia
    Justice
    Kinship
    Marginalisation
    Migration
    Multiculturalism
    National Identity
    Nationalism
    Nationhood
    Nativism
    Othering
    Policing
    Populism
    Postcolonial
    Race
    Racial Identity
    Racialisation
    Racism
    Radicalism
    Refugees
    Religion
    Resistance
    State Racism
    Stereotyping
    Stigmatisation
    Subjectivity
    Transnationalism
    Victimhood
    Whiteness


    Blog Collection

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019

Explore Identities at tandfonline.com/GIDE